Is green gas a viable alternative to shale gas?

by Search Gate staff. Published Thu 13 Jun 2013 13:32
Could investment in shale gas be better spent on green alternative?

Are policy-makers overlooking the potential of green alternatives in their “dash for gas”? Here, Rolf Stein of Advanced Plasma Power argues for the need for green gas in our energy mix...

As the Energy Bill makes its way through the legislative process, the debate about the potential contribution of shale gas to the UK’s energy mix continues. In some instances, the debate has become very heated with both sides using inflamed arguments. As a consequence, it can be difficult to discern the facts about shale, drilling and the best way to achieve an affordable, secure, low-carbon energy future for the UK.

There is certainly a need for more gas-fired power generation in the UK’s energy mix to replace dirtier, aging coal fired plants, particularly peaking plant. It has been identified as a priority technology by the chancellor to help increase energy security and bring down the cost of power. Shale gas has been cited as a priority source of gas for this purpose. However, the true impact of shale gas is unknown at this stage; whilst many potential sites in the UK and elsewhere have been identified it is still not known if they are economically viable. Much exploratory drilling will have to be done to find the answers. There are many other options for diversifying our energy mix and thereby achieving the aims of the Energy Bill and these should be expanded whilst the impact of shale remains an unknown. Green gas should be an important consideration at this juncture.

Those who are supportive of shale gas in the UK, point to the success story in the US and projections that it will be a net exporter of gas by the end of 2015. Those who are opposed to its development in the UK reference studies published this year revealing the huge costs associated with the US’s shale gas development that has taken more than 30 years and large government subsidies. As a result, many policy makers and business leaders in the UK and Europe fear that shale gas will not provide a cheap or quick solution. Furthermore, expansion of gas fired power stations, to the 37GW scenario, as painted by the chancellor in the Autumn Statement, will almost certainly hinder the UK’s ability to meet its long term carbon targets.

There is a risk that such policy decisions made now will lock us into a fossil fuel source that will leave the UK exposed to international gas markets in the future because the success of shale gas cannot be guaranteed. Projections by gas analysts all point to an upward trend in gas prices, which is a continuation of recent patterns. They believe demand will continue to outpace supply. However, not all gas need come from expensive, fossil fuel sources. Exposure to international price rises can be mitigated by investing in the UK’s advanced gasification industry, which will allow expansion of ‘green’ gas.

Investing in renewable fuels will reduce the UK’s reliance on potentially expensive and unproven shale gas exploration. The expansion of green gas would allow for gas expansion without the UK becoming wholly dependent on controversial shale gas exploration or on foreign gas for our energy security. Substitute natural gas (bio-SNG) can be created directly from abundant commercial and municipal waste and other biomass sources for injection into the national grid. Gasification of waste can also provide a sustainable and carbon negative means of diverting waste from landfill.

In addition, there are many policies working to support the development of this secure, indigenous source of fuel. Landfill taxes will hit £80 per tonne by 2014, so there is a need to find a more economically and sustainable means for diverting waste from landfill and the Green Investment Bank, which launched in November, has identified energy from waste as a key priority.

The future of global energy markets is uncertain so at this point the UK Government would be wise to invest in and encourage a diverse energy mix. With the population set to rise and with it demand for energy, the UK needs to plan for a future with reliable, secure, low-carbon and low cost energy and bio-SNG certainly has a role to play.

Sign up to receive Search Gate's FREE weekly newsletter with a review of all the latest green news and views

Opt Out

Comments about Is green gas a viable alternative to shale gas?

This debate one of the few times I've seen opposing sides discussing the issue in the same room
Hannah, London around 6 months, 1 week ago

Post a comment

Alert me of replies

You have characters left



Powered by SEO Rockstars
© All Rights Reserved.